Skip to main content

When someone asks AI for a business in New Orleans, who does it name?

We asked ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI Mode the questions buyers ask about 10 kinds of New Orleans business, three times each. 450 answers, checked November 17, 2026.

“My roof is leaking after a storm in New Orleans, which roofing company should I hire?”

ChatGPTBH Roofing NOLA
PerplexityTurnKey Roofing Contractor
AI ModeShifflett Roofing
Each engine named a different roofer first, all three times we asked. We asked 50 questions like it.

Pick a category. See who each one names.

Each engine answered each of the 5 questions 3 times: 15 answers per engine, 45 per category.

ChatGPT

  1. Commander's Palace, 14 of 15 answers
  2. Brennan's, 14 of 15 answers
  3. Ruby Slipper, 12 of 15 answers
  4. Atchafalaya, 11 of 15 answers
  5. Bearcat Cafe, 8 of 15 answers

Perplexity

  1. Commander's Palace, 15 of 15 answers
  2. Brennan's, 12 of 15 answers
  3. Atchafalaya, 9 of 15 answers
  4. Arnaud's, 6 of 15 answers
  5. Elizabeth's, 6 of 15 answers

Google AI Mode

  1. Commander's Palace, 11 of 15 answers
  2. Lux Cafe, 6 of 15 answers
  3. Court of Two Sisters, 5 of 15 answers
  4. Atchafalaya, 5 of 15 answers
  5. Cafe Malou, 5 of 15 answers

Google Maps

  1. Bayou Belle Cafe, 1st on Google Maps
  2. Lux Cafe, 2nd on Google Maps
  3. Crack'D Brunch, 3rd on Google Maps

Each AI: its top five across its 15 answers, more when businesses tie for fifth. Google Maps: the top 3 for "brunch new orleans", ads left out.

In every category, most businesses were named by just one AI

68%

of the 457 businesses named across 10 categories were named by only one of the three engines. Only 13% were named by all three.

By category: share of the businesses named that only one engine named.

Real estate81% named by only one engine
Plumbers80% named by only one engine
HVAC78% named by only one engine
Dentists72% named by only one engine
Family law64% named by only one engine
Hotels64% named by only one engine
Brunch62% named by only one engine
Roofers62% named by only one engine
Injury law56% named by only one engine
Med spas53% named by only one engine

Each AI has a different favorite dentist

Same five questions, asked three times. Each engine's top pick showed up in 12 of its 15 answers, and no dentist made all three top fives.

Answers naming each dentist, out of 15 per engine
DentistChatGPTPerplexityAI Mode
Concord Family Dental12 (this engine’s top pick)50
Comfort Smiles312 (this engine’s top pick)2
Mid-City Smiles6312 (this engine’s top pick)

Answers naming each dentist, out of 15 per engine.

The most-named business in each category

Answers naming it, out of 45. Brunch's leader was named most often (40). Real estate's, least (19).

Commander's PalaceBrunch40 of 45 answers
Mr. RooterPlumbers35 of 45 answers
Amber L. CainFamily law31 of 45 answers
Shifflett RoofingRoofers31 of 45 answers
Hotel MonteleoneHotels29 of 45 answers
Keefe'sHVAC29 of 45 answers
Belle Aesthetics and Fleur-De-Lis AestheticsMed spas, tied24 of 45 answers
Morris BartInjury law22 of 45 answers
Mid-City SmilesDentists21 of 45 answers
Mary Danna (Keller Williams)Real estate19 of 45 answers

Real estate counts agents, since most answers recommend a person. A brokerage counts only when no agent is named.

Which sites the answers cite

The five sites each category's answers cited most. Tap a category to see them.

Directory or listingBusiness's own sitePublication or guide
Dentists4 directories · 1 own site
dentistsranked.comDirectory or listing24 of 45 answers cited it
comfortsmilesdentistry.comBusiness's own site21 of 45 answers cited it
healthgrades.comDirectory or listing15 of 45 answers cited it
doctor.webmd.comDirectory or listing12 of 45 answers cited it
nextdoor.comDirectory or listing9 of 45 answers cited it
Family law4 directories · 1 own site
avvo.comDirectory or listing24 of 45 answers cited it
attorneys.superlawyers.comDirectory or listing19 of 45 answers cited it
justia.comDirectory or listing17 of 45 answers cited it
legalrank.coDirectory or listing9 of 45 answers cited it
waafirm.comBusiness's own site9 of 45 answers cited it
Real estate4 directories · 1 own site
zillow.comDirectory or listing29 of 45 answers cited it
realtor.comDirectory or listing24 of 45 answers cited it
homes.comDirectory or listing15 of 45 answers cited it
homelight.comDirectory or listing15 of 45 answers cited it
compass.comBusiness's own site15 of 45 answers cited it
Hotels3 directories · 2 guides
hotels.comDirectory or listing16 of 45 answers cited it
expedia.comDirectory or listing15 of 45 answers cited it
tripadvisor.comDirectory or listing12 of 45 answers cited it
leapaways.comPublication or guide12 of 45 answers cited it
cntraveler.comPublication or guide9 of 45 answers cited it
Med spas3 directories · 2 own sites
medspascout.comDirectory or listing30 of 45 answers cited it
medicalspaproviders.comDirectory or listing18 of 45 answers cited it
thecliniccompass.comDirectory or listing18 of 45 answers cited it
themodernplasticsurgery.comBusiness's own site15 of 45 answers cited it
chronosbhw.comBusiness's own site12 of 45 answers cited it
Plumbers3 directories · 1 own site · 1 guide
rotorooter.comBusiness's own site21 of 45 answers cited it
thumbtack.comDirectory or listing15 of 45 answers cited it
swbno.orgPublication or guide13 of 45 answers cited it
bestprosintown.comDirectory or listing12 of 45 answers cited it
serviceagent.aiDirectory or listing9 of 45 answers cited it
Injury law2 directories · 3 own sites
attorneys.superlawyers.comDirectory or listing11 of 45 answers cited it
chopinlawfirm.comBusiness's own site11 of 45 answers cited it
justia.comDirectory or listing10 of 45 answers cited it
frischhertzlaw.comBusiness's own site9 of 45 answers cited it
ljblegal.comBusiness's own site9 of 45 answers cited it
Brunch1 directory · 4 guides
neworleans.comPublication or guide27 of 45 answers cited it
timeout.comPublication or guide26 of 45 answers cited it
traveler.marriott.comPublication or guide17 of 45 answers cited it
opentable.comDirectory or listing16 of 45 answers cited it
theinfatuation.comPublication or guide15 of 45 answers cited it
Roofers1 directory · 3 own sites · 1 guide
bhroofingnola.comBusiness's own site15 of 45 answers cited it
turnkeyrenovators.comBusiness's own site12 of 45 answers cited it
anythingandeverythingnola.comBusiness's own site9 of 45 answers cited it
contractorsranked.comDirectory or listing9 of 45 answers cited it
theroofingbrief.comPublication or guide9 of 45 answers cited it

The most-cited roofing source was a roofer’s own site: bhroofingnola.com, in 15 of 45 answers. Separately, ChatGPT named BH Roofing NOLA first in all three runs of 2 of the 5 roofing questions. This study can’t say whether one causes the other.

HVAC4 own sites · 1 guide
keefes.comBusiness's own site21 of 45 answers cited it
bigeasyacheating.comBusiness's own site11 of 45 answers cited it
neworleanstimes.comPublication or guide11 of 45 answers cited it
bradley-air.comBusiness's own site9 of 45 answers cited it
gulfservicepros.comBusiness's own site9 of 45 answers cited it

The AIs' favorite brunch isn't in Google Maps' top 20

Searches for "brunch new orleans" with Google set to New Orleans. Google's results depend on where you search from.

Commander's Palace

40 of 45 AI answers
Not in the Google Maps top 20

8,800 Google reviews

Bayou Belle Café

1 of 45 AI answers
1st of Google Maps' top 3

463 Google reviews

3 of 9

categories where the three AIs' combined top three had no business in common with Google Maps' top 3, for searches like "brunch new orleans".

3 of 9

categories where the AIs' #1 pick was also in Google Maps' top 3, or 4 counting med spas, where two businesses tie for #1.

4 of 96

AI top-10 businesses we could match to a website had that site on Google's first page, across 20 searches. Yelp alone was 29 of 176 first-page results.

Key findings, method and every answer

Key findings

  • 68% of the 457 businesses named in a category were named by only one of the three engines. 13% were named by all three.
  • No dentist made all three engines’ top fives.
  • Commander's Palace was named in 40 of 45 brunch answers but wasn’t in the Google Maps top 20 for “brunch new orleans”.
  • 25 of the 50 most-cited sources (10 categories, top five each) were directories or listing sites. 16 were a business’s own site.
  • 4 of 96 AI top-10 businesses we could match to a website had that site on Google’s first page.

How to cite

Emerald Digital, “The AI Shortlist: New Orleans,” November 17, 2026. emerald.digital/research/ai-shortlist/new-orleans

Press: Matthew Berman, CEO and founder, or April Campos, director of operations. hello@emerald.digital

How we did it

  • On November 17, 2026 we asked three engines the same 5 questions for each of 10 kinds of business, 3 times each: 450 answers. The questions are written the way a buyer asks, and none names a business.
  • We asked each tool through its API, not the consumer app, so answers can differ from what the apps show. ChatGPT: gpt-4.1-mini with web search on, searching from New Orleans, temperature 0.7. Perplexity: sonar, temperature 0.7. Google AI Mode: location set to New Orleans, Louisiana, United States. Every answer, with these settings, is in the raw download below.
  • We listed every business each answer named and merged spelling variants. Directories, publications and neighborhoods don’t count as businesses. Then we checked every one of the 2,462 names against its answer’s text. A business counts once per answer that names it.
  • Real estate counts agents, since most answers recommend a person. A brokerage counts only when an answer names no agent.
  • Top-five lists include every business tied for fifth.
  • Google: 2 searches per category, like “brunch new orleans” and “best brunch in new orleans”, with Google set to New Orleans. Maps is the top 20 listings; the map top 3 is the map box on the regular results. Ads are left out. Websites come from each business’s Google Maps listing.
  • Limits: one day, one location, and AI answers change from run to run. This shows who gets named and which sites the answers cite, not why.
All 50 questions

Brunch

  1. best brunch in New Orleans
  2. where should I go for brunch in New Orleans this weekend
  3. top rated brunch spot in New Orleans
  4. I'm in New Orleans for one Sunday, where should I eat brunch?
  5. recommend a jazz brunch in New Orleans

Dentists

  1. best dentist in New Orleans
  2. who is a good family dentist in New Orleans
  3. top rated cosmetic dentist in New Orleans
  4. I just moved to New Orleans and need a dentist, who do you recommend?
  5. recommend a dental office in New Orleans, Louisiana

Family lawyers

  1. best divorce lawyer in New Orleans
  2. who is a good family law attorney in New Orleans
  3. top rated child custody lawyer in New Orleans
  4. I need a divorce attorney in New Orleans, who do you recommend?
  5. recommend a family law firm in New Orleans, Louisiana

HVAC

  1. best AC repair company in New Orleans
  2. who should I call to fix my air conditioning in New Orleans
  3. top rated HVAC company in New Orleans
  4. my AC stopped working in New Orleans, which company should I call?
  5. recommend an HVAC contractor in New Orleans, Louisiana

Hotels

  1. best hotel in New Orleans
  2. where should I stay in New Orleans for a weekend trip
  3. top rated boutique hotel in New Orleans
  4. I'm visiting New Orleans for the first time, which hotel should I book?
  5. recommend a hotel in the French Quarter

Injury lawyers

  1. best personal injury lawyer in New Orleans
  2. who should I call after a car accident in New Orleans
  3. top rated car accident attorney in New Orleans
  4. I got hurt in a wreck in New Orleans, which law firm should I hire?
  5. recommend a personal injury law firm in New Orleans, Louisiana

Med spas

  1. best med spa in New Orleans
  2. where should I get Botox in New Orleans
  3. top rated medical spa in New Orleans
  4. I want a facial and filler consult in New Orleans, which med spa should I try?
  5. recommend a med spa in New Orleans, Louisiana

Plumbers

  1. best plumber in New Orleans
  2. who should I call for a plumbing leak in New Orleans
  3. top rated plumbing company in New Orleans
  4. I need a plumber in New Orleans today, who do you recommend?
  5. recommend a plumbing company in New Orleans, Louisiana

Real estate agents

  1. best real estate agent in New Orleans
  2. who is a good realtor to help me buy a house in New Orleans
  3. top rated real estate agent for selling a home in New Orleans
  4. I'm moving to New Orleans and want to buy a house, which agent should I use?
  5. recommend a real estate brokerage in New Orleans, Louisiana

Roofers

  1. best roofing company in New Orleans
  2. who should I call to replace my roof in New Orleans
  3. top rated roofer in New Orleans
  4. my roof is leaking after a storm in New Orleans, which roofing company should I hire?
  5. recommend a roofing contractor in New Orleans, Louisiana
Roofers: answers naming each business. All engines out of 45; each engine out of 15.
BusinessAIChatGPTPerplexityGoogle AI ModeGoogle map listing
Shifflett Roofing3198141st
Lapeyre Roofing2761011Not in the top 3
Roof Squad20578Not in the top 3
Anything and Everything Roofing20938Not in the top 3
Storm Guard Roofing of New Orleans13391Not in the top 3
BH Roofing NOLA121200Not in the top 3
Perdomo Roofing12408Not in the top 3
Westbank Roofing10901Not in the top 3
Garcia Roofing100553rd
Priority Roofing8035Not in the top 3

AI: answers naming it, of 45. Engine columns: of 15. Map: place in Google Maps' top 3 for "roofing company new orleans".

Not on the list?

Tell us your business. We'll ask the same questions and show you who AI names instead of you, and which sites the answers cite. Free.

Matt runs it by hand and emails you the answers. No call unless you ask.